Too young to die

Email
Print

She looks like a fragile, scared little girl as she places a bunch of blue and white flowers at the foot of a tree. They were the favourite colours of Robert Spence (19), the guy she’d hoped to marry, Sandi Larkin says.

“I put fresh flowers here every day. I’ll do that forever. I talk to Robbie every day but I’ll never be able to hold his hand again.”

Robert was killed instantly near the tree on the notorious road through Target Kloof in Port Elizabeth when he was thrown from a car. The driver was 17 and allegedly drunk when he lost control at high speed. The car crashed over the centre barrier, rolled and slammed into the tree.

The driver walked away from the wreck with a broken arm and jaw but Robert was dead.

“Robbie once got out of a car on a highway because the driver was too drunk,” Sandi says. “I don’t know what was going through his mind that night. If only I had stopped him when he wanted to carry on partying.”

Matric finals are almost upon her but while her classmates at Victoria Park High School in Walmer, Port Elizabeth, prepare for the exams Sandi has no idea how she’s going to pass.

She’s only 17 and her dreams have been shattered by the tragic accident which could have been avoided.

They were at a house party for learners, the adults weren’t home and alcohol was flowing. Then Robert and the 17-year-old carried on partying at a club and drove home with the unlicensed youth behind the wheel of the car his mother had given him.

Perhaps something good can come from this tragedy if it could serve as a warning to parents and other young people. Even after Robert’s death many youngsters still get drunk in local clubs and then drive, Sandi says.

“Any parent who gives their 17-year-old child a car to drive without a licence might as well give them an AK-47 and send them to Sandton City,” says Robert’s mother, Lianda Sutherland of East London.

“The thing that saddens me most is there were so many opportunities to prevent the tragedy. If I’d known then what I know now I would have sat outside that club knitting and waiting for them to finish partying and driven them home safely.

“The accident has affected so many young lives, most of them in matric. I wish kids would have the courage to be the ‘baddie’ friend and take away the car keys. Don’t stand at the funeral with regrets, knowing you could have made a difference. Phone your parents; so what if mom is mad at 2 am. Trust me, your mom will get over it.

“We want to see you grow up – not bury you.”

*Police are investigating a case of culpable homicide.



Thank you for sending us your comment.


Terms of use:

YOU editors reserve the right to edit or delete any and all comments received.

All comments received could be used for publication in YOU magazine or any related Media24 brands.

Comments are moderated and published or deleted based on the following criteria:
  • The relevance of the comment to the article
  • Offensive content
  • Suspicious usernames and/or e-mail addresses
  • Duplication of opinion and/or comments
  • Comments on older articles might not be processed
  • YOU encourages freedom of speech and the expression of diverse views. The views of users published on YOU are therefore their own and do not necessarily represent the views of YOU.

Comments (35)


  1. Jaxjdv
    2011/09/20 10:49:57 AM
    Thankfully I have never been in this situation, however I do foresee a chance to prevent this from happening. Mothers, I remember growing up, my mother would take me to the party, check if the parents were there, My own father used to walk me up to the front door when I was 18, just to make sure the parents were there! Perhaps we have given our children too much freedom? Are we such a bad generation that what our parents did for us was not good enough? Lianda, my cousin died in a car crash many years ago, his parents went around offering hope and support to the rest of the family, still today they do this, and the reason they do: It is what he would have wanted. Hold on to the love, let go of the anger and hate. And for those of us who have not yet lost our children, let us learn from this unfortunate tragedy, to improve our parenting and hold our children closer to us. Lianda, and to all Roberts friends, my heart breaks for you, but allow Robert to live in your heart from now, that way, you will always carry him with you.
  2. Lianda
    2011/05/20 09:46:24 AM
    Damien, there is NO evidence what so ever that there was another car involved. This is just a story started by the kids involved to make themselves feel better - the forenstic evidence has proven without a doubt who was driving, what speed they were doing, and what appened at 2:22am on the 5 June 2010. It does not really matter though, how the event occured, it did, and someone died - just another alcohol, underage, dead - 15 000 people die on SA rroads every year and more than half are Alcohol related. ever wondered what the stats are for how many are Children, Teenagers just like you who think you can cheat death, it will never happen to you - NEWS GLASH my son was one of you, he was your friend, your protector, so why not honour Robert in Death as he did you his friends in life - rather learn the lseeon spread the work, and DONT DRINK, Underage and DON'T Drive if you have been drinking! AND DON'T SPEED - Yes speed does kill the poster is not telling you lies ~~~ If just half of you reading this took note, we could reduce the death tool on our roads. There would be a whole lot less Angel Mom's out there.
  3. gwen griessel
    2011/04/24 06:42:21 PM
    If only those people who keep making those silly comments were in Sandi's shoes,or Lianda's- i was a good mate of Robbies, and saw the passion he put into everything he did, and the love he gave his mom and family- you only know that hurt when you feel it, we all deal with the pain in our own ways, but Lianda is trying to get all the teens driving drunk, to wake up, when you get behind that wheel drunk, its beyond selfish, its not about you anymore, but the people who's life you endangering by driving under the influence, wake up man, stop being silly! They just trying to make you see how dangerous it is, and we all miss him every single day, Christmas, birthdays, easter, holidays, these will all be a constant reminder every day! It'll never go away, so if you can prevent that pain in someone elses life, the least you can do is try!
  4. Damien Wilson
    2011/03/08 02:44:31 PM
    the article failed to mention that the accident was acctually caused by a white BMW that jumped a red light and smacked into the golf.
  5. Lianda Sutherland
    2010/09/20 11:01:04 PM
    Taahira - trust me it is not he call you want to receive EVER - my call came at 3:07am on the 5th June 2010 - I was home alone, the shock and the disbelief is unimaginable -
  6. taahira
    2010/09/07 01:06:30 PM
    irrespective if the 17 yr old had a licence or not, the fact is one life is lost and the other ones future is unknown. they must have trusted each other well enuf to drive togetha, so imagine how the driver is feeling. robbie will never come back and i hope that God gives everyone that knew robbie peace. yes his girlfriend is young, and she is heartsore. leave her be. time heals all wounds. imagine getting that call to say your loved one has passed on?? dont people think before they make ignorant comments? whats wrong with us that we have become so heartless? i can never imagine this happening to me, can you?
  7. Lianda Sutherland
    2010/08/15 08:58:28 PM
    Thank you Sharoda and all the others that commented - this has been a life changing experience for us all - and for the record the YOU DID NOT PAY FOR THE ARTICLE- I approached the magazine to run the story, it is a story that hadto be told and yes we did achieve what we set out to do.
    To annoymous
    2010/07/20 08:57:48 PM I can only say one thing - your were obviously at the same party and at my sons wake - sadly YOU COULD HAVE STOPPED THIS ACCIDENT TO - it that why you are so bitter and nasty - there are many kids who were involved and never onec dii we blame anyone - and if you recall my words at my sons wake - NO ONE IS TO BLAME FOR THIS TRAGIC ACCIDENT. I am in constant contact with the driver via sms and have met with him and his mom - we are all working with one common goal - that all the kids involved SURVIVE this with minimal long term problems -
    Once again thanks to Pieter and YOU for running the story -
  8. SHERODA
    2010/08/13 12:23:03 PM
    Who says that when you are Sandy's age you could not find that someone that you want to spend your rest of you life with . It is called TRUE LOVE !!!! You don't have to be old to find that someone . God send Robert to Sandy because He know they were meant to be together till the end of days. If anyone do not believe it as true then you do not believe in Love at all. For some people it takes a while to find that someone to spend they whole lives with and some others meat them at a young age. I think people everyone must thank God for that special someone in their live that God sent to them and stop attacking Sandy for loving Robert with all her heart like God attended.
  9. good guy*
    2010/08/03 01:15:16 PM
    GO BUBBLES!!! i think that annoymous needs to grow up cleary the man or woman has no guts to tell the people who they really are. only Cowards hide their true identity
  10. bubbles
    2010/08/02 04:04:58 PM
    annoymous if you have nothing better to say to a Mother and Grieving 17 year old please dont comment.....in my opinion i think u a self centered bitch who sits on her arse and has nothing else better to do then to judge other people...are u jealous of the fact that maybe you dont get enough attention at home.....you dont know what sandi is going thru and tell me how do u know they were fighting that night u maybe a friend of sandi? but cant confront her so please do us all a favour and GROW UP!
  11. Lianda Sutherland
    2010/08/02 03:56:18 PM
    I have read and re-read the comments for a few days - and would like the following facts knows:
    Annoymous
    2010/07/20 02:26:09 PM - there is nothing ONE SIDED about the article, you just missed the point sadly!
    annoymous
    2010/07/20 08:57:48 PM - What part did you have to do with the tragic events that the guilt is eating you up, which is making you nasty. NEVER at any one time was anyone blamed for the accident - despite the fact that there were numerious people WHO COULD HAVE PREVENTED this tragic event. My sons IRISH WAKE was in accordence with ROBERTS WISHES - which we honoured. SO get your facts right please. The 17 year old driver DID NOT TAKE the girls home that evening, the boys were in the back of the car being driven by a SOBER 18 YEAR OLD WITH A LICENCE.
    If you want to voice your opinion, have the guts to put your name there. Don't hide like a coward.
    And lianda 2010/07/28 12:36:19 PM - kindly contact me please as your book club really could do with a motivational talk, which I will gladly deliver free of charge - you bunch of book worms missed the entire point of the article - the 3000plus emails we received from other kids shows it reached the people we needed it to - Kids don't listen to adults, they identify with other kids HELLO GET THE POINT - we needed Sandi to to her story so they could identify with her - and realize tragic accidents do happen!!! next time THINK BEFORE YOU TALK, age should give you wisdom, which sadly you 12 lacked!!!!!
  12. Hilary
    2010/08/02 11:55:34 AM
    How does it help for people to pull apart a tragic accident and lay an attack on Sandi - sure she may be 17 years old but the pain of her loss is just as bad as if she were 35! She will move on in life but will carry this memory with her forever! Yes Robert's mother will also carry the pain of loss of her son for the rest of her life. Ladies of the bookclub please tell us - did you have a glass of wine in your hands whilst discussing this matter? Why if you found the matter boring was the time given to critizise the article and people involved?
  13. Lianda Sutherland
    2010/08/01 02:24:42 PM
    Would the person refered to as LIANDA be so kind as to contact me privately - I'm on face book or at kelirosh@telkomsa.net. You need to be informed of a few real hard facts. I am Roberts Mom and Sandi is one of my kids - next time you decide to write something ask yourself - will it hurt anyone? will it make an already explosive situation any better or worse. Will it actually help anyone? and will it make anyone but yourself feel any better - Sandi never wrote the article I DID!!!!! and there is a very reason it was writen the way it was - so kindly get intouch with me and I'll send you the draft outlines of who where why and when things were written and the reasons it was done that way - and for your info and your book club - IT WAS A HUGH SUCCESS - the got the message across, it touch home to many young girls who next time will think twice before they let their friends drink and drive - sadly you are only one of two negative feedbacks we had from the story, and with over 3000 good ones, we onbvioulsy hit a nerve - PLEASE GOD you never stand where we are right now - this is only the start of a very big campaign, so next time you and your book club want to offer an opinion, consider the reasons things are being done before you voice your opinion. Besides hurting a lot of people you missed the point completely. I would be happy to discuss it with you, explain to you what our aim is and how we intend to reach the end result. Would love to bring your 12 ladies on board as part of this campaign. THanks Lianda
  14. Shelley
    2010/08/01 09:34:55 AM
    Sandi and Linanda and all that are affected by the negative comments written by these people who obviousely have nothing better to do than to poke their noses into something that really has nothing to do with them. Their comments and accusations mean nothing. Sandi, you are so strong, don't let them intimidate you in anyway you keep moving forward and show them who the better person is at the end of the day. Feel ashamed of yourselves for the negative coments you just added to their pain by making comments about people that you don't even know!!! Get to know someone before you just make stupid assumptions about them.
  15. Lianda Sutherland
    2010/08/01 08:00:37 AM
    I would like to thank PIETER and YOU magazine for writing the article, and editing the article to the finished piece. We have received over 3000 emails mainly from school going children, who IDENTIFY with Sandy, the driver and the problem we are currently facing in South Africa. for the TWO negative remarks we received, there always has to be some person who will talk before they actually think about the effects of what they have to say - thankfully 2 negative stupid comments out of 3000 is acceptable. Robert's story and the continuing awareness to the problem will hopefully save many lives. To the book club, please contact me via facebook, as I woud like to send you a copy of the book as soon as it has been published. It may just save one of your children, granchildren or greatgran children.
    There are a number of facts, I think you 12 ladies need to hear, and I am quiet willing to travel to where you are to deliver them in person.Then maybe next time before you say some really stupid things, you'll think twice - the effects of what you wrote have been soul destroying for some of the kids involved -
  16. warren
    2010/07/29 08:54:55 PM
    to the person who calls themself lianda in this comment block on to young to die.
    you need to remember one thing no matter if u gave birth or lived and loved them its the same thing love is love... so maybe u shud grow up and realise that other people hurt and he was loved by others and loved others aswell
  17. warren immerman
    2010/07/29 08:13:27 PM
    to annonymous

    i am roberts uncle and was his best friend
    he loved sandy and she loved him dearly
    so a loss is very tragic for all parties
    so my message to u is GO TO HELL

    if u have a problem u can contact me
  18. Disgusted
    2010/07/29 07:34:11 PM
    I find you all so callus in the way you attack Sandi. For goodness sake, where are your hearts. You book club ladies are disgustingly cruel to dare say what you have. She has every right to be angry and sad - she did not go to You magazine, they came to her - she is only 18 years old and you still ;ve to tear the poor girl apart after her loss. Take no notice of these women Sandi, they should stick to Desperate Housewives!!!
  19. JAY
    2010/07/29 02:49:23 PM
    Speaking as a young mind... I think that a tragedy like this can destroy you at such a young age after all young loves the best. My great sympathies go out to Sandi and Roberts friends and family. As for people who have absolutely anything negative to say against Sandi you obviously dont know your place and dont care how Sandi or Roberts mom is feeling, just seems a little disrespectful. RIP Robert Spence
  20. lianda
    2010/07/28 12:36:19 PM
    was this article written about sandy or about the boy who died. was it written to warn us about drunk driving in teens or about the girl who wants our sympathy? i am a mother of two and couldnt imagine them dying, so all my sympathy to the mother who has lost her baby boy. sandy is a child and will grow up and marry someone else, i find it tacky of her to make this article about her. i took this article to my book club and all woman were agreeing on the same line. its all good her friends sent in here defensive arguments but as an adult,which you soon will all be, i know that she is still a baby compared to whats left in life for her. you cant tell me she has just become widowed cat lady that has reached the end of her life. doubt it. she still needs to grow up ALOT and hopefully one day we will read an article by her about the death of robert and the dangers of drunk driving in teens. an article that wont bore us to tears about her when we bought the magazine to read reality articles. in no way am i slandering her, i am putting this as a perspective from 12 woman (including me) who all agreed to send this through.
  21. Joanne Weir
    2010/07/26 04:56:56 PM
    We lost our mother and grandparents and nobody knows what it is like unless they have gone through it. This happened in 1966 in Welkom, and I (7 yrs old) will never forget when I had to call my father to the door. Jimmy Heasman has carried on with his life, his kids dont even know about it as they felt it is not neccessary for them to know. The message from his wife is "whats the problem, I also grew up without a mother" Can I forgive? Never!!! I am not bitter but cant help wondering what our life would have been like if they were still alive. You always remember the birthday and the day they were killed. It is easy to sit on the sideline and comment. If you have not been through it then you have no idea of what it is like. It changes your life forever.
  22. Bianca
    2010/07/25 07:45:00 PM
    To the person who said Sandi is making this all about her, you most probably have a lot of hatred in your heart.

    Sandi loves Robert dearly and too loose someone you love is not a easy situation to deal with. Have you never lost someone close too you?????
    You have a lot of soul searching to do.
    Just like Roberts mom lost her son, Sandi lost the man she loved.

    And Sandi you don't even listen to what they say... it takes time to heal and girl your allowed to cry.
    Keep believing that you will meet again because you will.

    Robert RIP you will be dearly missed...
    Keep your eyes over your love Sandi and your friends and family..

  23. tara
    2010/07/25 07:07:40 PM
    to annoymous who made the shocking comment about sandi ("Sandi making this all about you, in my opinion, is very bad taste. You will move on to another boyfriend and then a husband but a mother lost her son and another mother is fighting for her sons life, a 17 year old son of a mother is going to live to regret his own bad choice that he made that night. If you want money or attention i suggest you write your exams, pass it and get a job.") i really think you need to re evaluate your sources becoz if you do personally know sandi you'd know shes NOT the type of person to get status from a death especially that of her boyfriend. she loved him very much and spoke of him everyday! great, you're all high and mighty becoz you made a comment so vile but hiding behind "annoymous" is cowardess! you really should think about what you say and how you say them...you could cause a lot of damage!!!
  24. ...
    2010/07/22 12:47:10 PM
    wat difference does it make if the driver has or hasnt got a license!!!
    anything can happen, having a license makes no difference and doesnt prevent anything!!!
    its being wise enough to kno when your able to drive and when not to drive!!
    so sad that a life was taken because of 1 selfish person!!1
  25. Riszell
    2010/07/22 12:02:37 AM
    There is a lesson to be learnt from this, i am a friend of Roberts and i know, just like all his friends do, he would never get into the car with someone that is drunk. To everyone reading this, young students and parents, please know where your children are and students, take caution at places you will be going to, dont engage yourself with under-age drinking, dont allow yourself to be a statistic. To Sandy, Mrs Sutherland and all Robbies friends and family, on behalf of matric 08 class we are sorry for your loss, our prayers are with you all. Rest in peace Rob.
  26. Mom
    2010/07/21 02:28:40 PM
    It's sad but it was a tragic accident. My son also died the same way - car accident -flown out the car and hit the tree and died instantly while the car rolled his girl friend died and his sister brain split in half - that was 3 years ago and is still in a coma will never come out of it. The driver of the other car survived and they were friends - but do you really think that a friend would kill a friend. . All you need to do is forgive otherwise you will be un-happy for the rest of your life. and that is not what our late children would have wanted. What if the role was reversed you would want the other family to forgive you. It will not bring our children back but in our hearts we know that they are in a better place.
  27. Ackim Phiri
    2010/07/21 11:36:33 AM
    It is very sad that a very energetic youth could be lost at such an early stage. who is going to drive our economy forward if we loose such people. I pray that the girl should find comfort in God. stop crying over spilt milk, Jehova is in control.
  28. Adriaan from Fochville
    2010/07/21 11:19:01 AM
    I am the father of two beautiful young gentleman and can not imagine myself losing one of them at least not knowing they were drunk. I am blassed they do not drink at least not when driving, both of them smoke though, weekends when they visit, the house is dark with all the sigarette smoke but i know, this "smoking" habit is not going to cause an accident on the way home! I do not promote smoking, myself like i assume by now everybody else know and acknowledge it is a very bad habit and people die because of smoking the difference is this stats do not say how many people die, how many people are abused, get cancer, how many families are broken up. The list is endless to what damage alcohol does. Thank you my children, when you drive home after a weekend you might have an accident and if it is because of alcohol somebody else will be to blame.
  29. Ginger Mary
    2010/07/20 09:14:49 PM
    Someone is always responsible for a drink drive related accident. Dont fool yourselves or your children because drunk driving is a choice. If you are on SA roads after 10:00 at night - you are at risk. South Africans need to get over this sick culture of drinking and driving. Getting behind the wheel after consuming alcohol is an irresponsible choice with serious concequences. The truth is, if the law doenst punish you - your conscience will........
  30. annoymous
    2010/07/20 08:57:48 PM
    How fragile can one be if you know you also had a part in events that lead to death. Is it because you have a guilty conscience that you were aslo over the legal limit and under age.

    How can it be ok for the "17 year old, unlicenced driver" to take you home after you had a fight with Robert. How come you did not mention that to the reporter? Or the fact that the fight with Robert was about getting so drunk on all the Brandy you two took to the house party?

    “Any parent who gives their 17-year-old child a car to drive without a licence might as well give them an AK-47 and send them to Sandton City,” says Robert’s mother, Lianda Sutherland of East London.
    How can a mother have her son's wake at a local pub if he died as a result of alcohol abuse and still drank to it.

    Being young, and teenages, we are capable of knowing what is right and wrong, and we decide what we want to do in life and we make our own choices regardless of what our parents teach us. Unfortunatly we leave them behind with sadness and loss and blaming other parents for our own mistakes.

    Sandi making this all about you, in my opinion, is very bad taste. You will move on to another boyfriend and then a husband but a mother lost her son and another mother is fighting for her sons life, a 17 year old son of a mother is going to live to regret his own bad choice that he made that night. If you want money or attention i suggest you write your exams, pass it and get a job.

    - this is without any prejudice to the mothers or sons involved

  31. annoymous
    2010/07/20 02:26:09 PM
    this story is very one sided. i feel like there isnt anyone to blame here. it was an accident and there was nothing anyone could have done to prevent it. sandi is still so young and will get over this sad time. someone high up must have big plans for the driver.
  32. Glynis
    2010/07/20 01:56:03 PM
    As tragic as this incident is, I blame the mother of the boy who drove the car. What mother in her right mind gives a boy of 17 a car to drive knowing, he has no licence. I had teenage kids my self, but I made the effort to take them to their parties and fetch them no matter what time it was. There should be a law that parents who allow their kids to drive their cars without a licence should be charged with negligence or even culpable homicide in instances of accidents which lead to a death of another person. Parents are well aware of what teenagers get up to at these parties and should start taking responsibility for their children. Why have kids if you don't instill values and responsibility into them.
  33. majorie chiwisha
    2010/07/20 08:25:43 AM
    it is unfortunate but the girl can still make it in life. she should get busy with other things like games and let her share everything she's thinking off. eventually, it will pass.
  34. Anthony Keyser
    2010/07/20 07:10:47 AM
    A tragic and unecessary loss of life , due to a few moments of negligance.
  35. Annemarie Lotter
    2010/07/18 09:11:32 PM
    This is only a drop in the ocean of what is going on in Por Elizabeth. If parents would just open their eyes to young girlf from the age of 14 using illegal substance I honestly do not understand this they should still be playing flippin dolls. These are girls from prominent schools. Parents wake up stop just handing out the money take stock of what your children are doing.

Copyright © 2010 Media24. All rights reserved.